**Disclaimer: The following is my opinion (and some of Dan’s–I like to allow him some input now and then). Your mileage may vary and you may have alternate opinions.
Let’s start with the first question most people ask…size:
Disneyland Resort:
2 parks (Disneyland and California Adventure)
.13 square miles
Walt Disney World Resort:
4 parks (Magic Kingdom, Animal Kingdom, EPCOT, and Hollywood Studios)
43 square miles
Do not judge these parks on size alone. We were there 5 days and still did not get to do everything in Disneyland. Park-hopping was a breeze as you are able to just walk across the esplanade to the other park. No buses or monorails required! I never realized how much I hate having to take buses to the other parks until this trip.
Hotels: WDW has more than 25 on-property options from Values to Deluxes. Disneyland resort offers only 3 on-site options none of which fall into the value category or even the moderate (cheapest around $300 plus a night). There are many, many off-site hotels that range in price from $79/night to upwards of $400. We stayed mid-range and I would argue that it was the best hotel we have ever stayed in even compared to WDW properties. We were literally a 5 minute walk and our hotel even had a water park complete with slides. Zero complaints about the staff or anything about the hotel actually!
Castle comparison: I have to give this one to WDW. Sleeping Beauty Castle at just over 75 feet does seem like a dwarf when compared to Cinderella Castle at a whooping 189 feet tall. The Matterhorn is pretty impressive as an alternate centerpiece though.
Rides: Some of the rides are draws as they are similar or identical to each other. There are rides. however, in Disneyland that you will not see in Florida: Mr. Toad’s Wild Ride, Snow White’s Scary Adventures, Indiana Jones, Pinnochio, etc. The exterior of It’s a Small World in California blows away the exterior of Florida’s version and I preferred California’s version of Pirates (Dan liked Florida’s version better). California Adventure offers Cars Land (If you compare Radiator Springs Racers to Test Track, RSR would come in 1st place) and Pixar Pier, which are both really well done and just lovely at night.
Cost: cost for the park tickets are slightly cheaper at Disneyland vs. WDW but that is where the savings ends. Food is astronomically expensive in the CA. parks even by theme park standards. Another issue is there is no free transportation from the airport like the Magical Express so you are on your own for a car rental, car service or Uber when flying into LAX or SNA. That alone added another $200 plus to our trip.
Cast Members: Dan says this is a draw as he finds most cast members to be nice and extremely helpful on both coasts. I feel we had better experiences with the cast members in California overall. We had a great interaction with the first one we spoke to, a security guard and also a 20 minute conversation with a chef who came out of the kitchen to tell us wonderful stories about Walt. However, we were both really thrown off by the cast members walking around the parks in uniform in other sections of the park that they did not work in. We saw cast members getting off the bus fully dressed and walking down the street. This is something that you would never see in WDW.
Planning: Hands-down Disneyland wins. No pre-planning meal reservations or getting FastPasses 3 months in advance. Disneyland still uses the paper FastPass system though for $10/pp/per day you can purchase MaxPass that works much like the electronic FastPass system and I would argue even better with its inclusion of free photo downloads. I will not bore you with all the details of the MaxPass, but it is a worthy investment if you decide to travel out west. The lack of MagicBands did throw us off a bit, but we brought lanyards with us for our park tickets and that worked out fine.
Disney Bubble: We stayed off-property, so I am not sure if it feels different to stay on-site, but WDW allows you to get on site and not have to deal with the outside world at all. Our hotel was about a block away and we had to walk past a McDonald’s, Panera and quite a few homeless people and street vendors. It was tough to walk past people struggling and go about our day not thinking about them.
Food: Taking cost out of it, Disneyland offered on the whole healthier options and it was easy to not just get stuck eating theme park food plus In-N-Out Burger is right in Anaheim. There are options like I mentioned, Panera and such, if you do not want to eat in the parks. More options for gluten free are available at WDW vs. Disneyland though.
Crowds: Maybe we were just lucky, but the parks seemed empty as compared to what we typically encounter in Florida. This might not always be the case though.
Weather: I can only speak for the summertime, but I would never, ever, ever, ever go to Florida in August. It was hot in California, but not unbearable and the nights were beautiful and cool.
Layout: The layouts are similar when comparing the Magic Kingdom to Disneyland, but DL does seem to suffer from planning issues when it comes to ease of cutting through and shortcuts. I think this boils down to there was no way Walt understood just how popular the park would become. One major issue we felt was lack of bathrooms or maybe our lack of being able to find the bathrooms. It seems that every corner in WDW presents another gloriously themed potty. This did not appear to be the case in DL or even California Adventure as I found myself quite often adding another couple hundred steps to find a bathroom (when it is 11am and you are at 11,000 steps already this is not a good thing)
Final thoughts: DL is the original park that Walt walked in (Personally, this made the park feel that much more magical and special as Walt’s touches could be seen all around the parks; make sure to take a peek above the firehouse to see his apartment). Overall, it is tough to compare as they both have their pros and cons. I think any Disney fan should take the trip to the West Coast to see the first park and judge for yourself. I would say, overall, shockingly Disneyland comes out a little ahead of WDW for me. The size was not a negative, in my opinion, and the ease of park-hopping made it even more fantastic. The cost is a hinderance that might mean it will be a while before we head out again, but I would definitely not hesitate to book another trip in the future. Dan would go back but is more on the fence when it comes to picking a favorite. There are things he loved about the California parks, but struggled a bit more with the layout issues, lack of Disney bubble and he missed seeing where all the cast members were from (we quickly found out that 90% of the DL cast members are from California). He does agree we should go back one day. I hope next time we can stay on property and see the difference that experience brings.